Latest update: November 16, 2026 - 5 min read
5 Strategies for Rising Vehicle Ownership and Operating Costs
For US finance and HR leaders who reimburse employees for driving their own cars.
Owning and running a car keeps getting more expensive: vehicle prices, insurance, maintenance, tires and fuel. Rising costs don’t have to mean a bigger bill for your vehicle reimbursement program, or underpaid drivers.
Five strategies help: stop paying tax on allowances, move off one-size-fits-all mileage rates, keep your FAVR program compliant, close gaps in license and insurance checks, and check what you pay for your reimbursement provider.
Driversnote sets reimbursement rates using a comprehensive vehicle cost database, which tracks costs in local markets across all 50 US states.
What are we seeing in vehicle costs this year?
- The average new vehicle sold for a record $51,109 in October 2026, according to Kelley Blue Book
- Used vehicle values reached a two-and-a-half-year high in March 2026, according to Cox Automotive
- Car insurance costs have risen about 50% over the past five years, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics
- Maintenance and repair costs have risen 45% over the past five years, about twice the rate of inflation, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics
- Tire prices have risen almost 30% since 2020, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics
- Gasoline prices were about 37% higher in October 2026 than a year earlier, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics
For current reimbursement rates, see the current IRS mileage rate.
No one can predict where costs go next, but the trend has run one way for years. Quick fixes, like raising a flat allowance or cutting it, can cost more later or add admin work. These strategies protect your budget and your drivers, whatever costs do next.
1. Why stop paying tax on flat car allowances?
A flat car allowance paid outside an accountable plan counts as wages. Drivers pay income tax and FICA on it, and the company pays its share of FICA too. That money goes to taxes instead of covering the car.
In one program design, a regional director on a $1,125 monthly allowance took home $687 after tax, so $438 a month was lost before any of it reached the car. Across 17 drivers, switching to a tax-free FAVR program removed $82,438 a year in tax waste. See the full example.
2. Why move your vehicle reimbursement program off the IRS rate?
The IRS standard mileage rate is simple, but it’s a national average. It pays the same per mile in a high-cost city as in a low-cost town. It also pays nothing extra toward insurance, registration and depreciation, so low-mileage drivers are underpaid and high-mileage drivers can be overpaid.
In a nonprofit’s program design, the lowest-mileage qualifying driver got $317 a month at the IRS rate. Under the budget FAVR plan, the same driver got $522. A review of how your team drives shows who is under- or over-reimbursed today, and which method fits each group:
| Annual business miles | Method that usually fits |
|---|---|
| Occasional drivers | IRS standard mileage rate |
| Regular drivers under 5,000 | Accountable plan allowance (tax-free) |
| 5,000 or more | FAVR |
3. How do you keep an existing FAVR program compliant?
FAVR payments are tax-free only for drivers who meet the IRS rules: enough business miles, a car that’s new and expensive enough, and insurance that meets the program’s limits. A driver who falls short on any of these can have their payments taxed. IRS FAVR rules and requirements lists each one.
Rates also go stale as prices change. Refreshing the cost data every year keeps payments fair and the base vehicle within IRS limits. A yearly review is also the time to check whether a different base vehicle or retention period would lower costs. How to calculate a FAVR allowance explains how the rates are built.
4. How do you reduce the hidden costs of risk?
Some costs stay out of sight until something goes wrong, like an accident while an employee is driving on an expired license or without enough insurance. Checking every driver’s license and insurance protects the company and keeps FAVR payments compliant. A Driversnote FAVR program includes license and insurance validation and an annual vehicle check.
5. Are you paying too much for your reimbursement provider?
Managed reimbursement fees add up per driver, every year. Compare what you pay with what you get: rate design, local cost data, tracking, validation, payments and support.
Driversnote runs FAVR programs for $294 per participant per year, with no setup fees or add-ons, and admins are free. That covers program design, yearly rate refreshes, the mileage tracking app, validation and support.
Want to see how your program holds up? Book a free consultation and we’ll show you where you can save.
FAQ
Start by removing tax waste and matching the method to how much each person drives. For staff who drive 5,000 or more business miles a year, FAVR pays for local costs tax-free.
Not necessarily. A smaller tax-free payment can be worth more than a larger taxed one, and rates can be set so that no driver takes home less than today.
It's how a company pays employees back for driving their own cars for work. The most common methods are a flat car allowance, a rate per mile such as the IRS standard mileage rate, and FAVR, which combines a fixed monthly payment with a rate per mile.
At least once a year, because vehicle prices, insurance, fuel and IRS limits all change.
